Arch Hellen Med, 16(5), September-October 1999,
516-524
GUIDELINES
Dietary guidelines
for adults in Greece*
MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND WELFARE
Supreme Scientific Health Council
*Following a decision by the Supreme Scientific Health
Council (SSHC), the Department of Hygiene and Epidemiology of the University of
Athens Medical School undertook the development of dietary guidelines for Greeks,
with reference at this stage to the nutritional needs of healthy adults. Distinguished
scientists, from both Greece and abroad, contributed to the development of a draft
document under the coordination of Antonia Trichopoulou, MD and Pagona Lagiou,
MD. The scientists who were members of the SSHC at the time the guidelines were
development were:
- P. Bakopoulos, Director
General, Division of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Welfare
- C. Basiaris, Division of
Infectious Diseases, General Hospital of Rio, Patras
- J. Chatzis, Dean, University
of Ioannina Medical School
- M. Dalakas, Professor, University
of Athens Medical School
- G. Delidis, Dean, University
of Crete Medical School
- P. Gargalianos, Director,
Department of Internal Medicine, Gene ral Hospital "G. Gennimatas", Athens
- E. Kalokerinos, President,
Hellenic Medical Association
- C. Karapanos, President,
Hellenic Dental Association
- G. Kavadias, President,
National Drug Administration
- A. Koutselinis, Dean, University
of Athens Medical School
- J. Kremastinou, Professor,
National School of Public Health
- M. Lazanas, Director, 2nd
Department of Internal Medicine, Tzanio General Hospital of Pireus
- N. Legakis, Professor, University
of Athens Medical School (Vice-President of SSHC)
- G. Papoutsakis, Director
General, Division of Public Health, Mini stry of Health and Welfare
- S. Raptis, Professor, University
of Athens Medical School
- N. Stathakis, Dean, University
of Thessalia Medical School
- T. Theocharidis, Professor,
TUFTS University Medical School, Boston, USA
- T. Dimitriou, Dean, University
of Thrace Medical School
- A. Tourkantonis, Dean, University
of Thessaloniki Medical School
- D. Trichopoulos, Professor,
University of Athens Medical School (President of SSCH)
- D. Vagionas, President,
Hellenic Association of Pharmacists
In addition to the SSHC members,
the following Hellenic Medi cal Societies contributed to the finalization of the
dietary guideline document:
- Hellenic Medical Society
of Obesity
- Hellenic Cancer Society
- Hellenic Society of Chemotherapy
- Hellenic Society of Gastrointestinal
Oncology
- Hellenic Society of Gerontology
- Hellenic Society of Endocrinology
- Hellenic Society of Health
Promotion and Health Education
- Hellenic Society of Hygiene
and Epidemiology
- Hellenic Society of Internal
Medicine
- Hellenic Society of Internists-Oncologists
- Hellenic Society of Invasive
Radiology
- Hellenic Society of Nutrition
and Foods
- Hellenic Society of Oncology
- Hellenic Society of Pediatrics
- Hellenic Society of Preventive
Medicine
- Hellenic Society of Psychiatry
- Hellenic Society of Public
Health
- Hellenic Society of Research
on Breast Cancer
- Hellenic Society of Social
Pediatrics and Health Promotion
- Hellenic Society of Infections
in Surgery
- Hellenic Society of Tumor
Markers
- Professional Union of Greek
Gastroenterologists
1. INTRODUCTION
Food availability has shaped human history over the centuries,
and nutritional deficiencies remain critical determinants of the nosological spectrum
in many popu lation groups of the developing world. In the developed countries,
however, the face of malnutrition has changed. Known nutritional deficiencies
persist in some segments of the population and new deficiency syndromes continue
to be discovered (e.g. folic acid in relation to neural tube defects). Most nutrition-related
disorders, however, can be traced to nutritional excesses and qualitative aberrations
which take their toll on the adult population through such common diseases as
cardiovascular or cancers of several sites.
Until the end of World War II,
Greece had many problems that are still common in developing countries. Since
1950, however, economic growth has been accompanied by the reduction of premature
mortality and an increase in the incidence of coronary heart disease and several
forms of cancer.13 High prevalence of tobacco smoking and
some aspects of urbanization4,5 may have contributed to the
unfavorable trends in adult morbidity, but there has been increased recognition
and epidemiological substantiation that a major factor underlying these trends
has been a shift in the dietary habits of a large and increasing segment of
the Greek population away from the traditional Mediterranean diet and towards
westernized dietary practices and lifestyles. Consequently, the formulation
and implementation of dietary guidelines has gained momentum in the scientific
cycles as well as among the public at large (fig. 1).
2. FOOD-BASED
DIETARY GUIDELINES (FBDG)
Dietary guidelines at the nutrient
level generally provide three values per nutrient: the Lowest Threshold Intake
(LTI: the nutrient intake below which, on the basis of current knowledge, almost
all individuals will be unlikely to maintain metabolic integrity according to
the criterion chosen for each nutrient; it is equal to the mean nutrient intake
minus two standard deviations), the Average Requirement (AR: the mean nutrient
intake in a population) and the Population Reference Intake (PRI: this corresponds
to what used to be called "recommended dietary allowance" or RDA and is the
nutrient intake which will meet the needs of virtually all healthy people in
a population; it is equal to the mean nutrient intake plus two standard deviations).6
Dietary guidelines at the nutrient level are useful concepts because they allow
the operationalization of dietary requirements to meet metabolic needs and minimize
the likelihood of nutritional deficiencies. However, they are of little use
to the average consumer who thinks in terms of foods rather than nutrients.
Food-based dietary guidelines (FBDG), conversely, can be both scientifically
sound and general ly intelligible for the following reasons:
- Diet is made of foods and
food-, rather than nutrient- based dietary guidelines are easier for the public
to follow.
- The epidemiological evidence
concerning diet in relation to health and disease relies on food intakes,
whereas the evidence concerning nutrients is based on animal studies or is
inferred from epidemiological investigations under the constraints of existing
food composition tables. Compounds of unknown physiologic consequences cannot
be accommodated through RDAs, whereas they can be indirectly accounted for
through FBDG.
- Patterns of food intake may
be more relevant to health and disease than intakes of specific foods or particular
nutrients and only FBDG can directly address this issue.
- BDG can incorporate aspects
of the socio-cultural environment that affect food availability and choices,
and can overcome behavioral obstacles that hinder their implementation.
3. THE
SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE ON DIET AND HEALTH
There is a substantial body of
evidence concerning diet in relation to health. The evidence has been reviewed
in a publication by the United States National Research Council7
and more recent developments have been summarized in several publications.6,814
Important research on diet and health has also been undertaken in Greece, early
on by the Greek contributors to the Seven Countries Study15
and later by several groups working on cancer, cardiovascular and childhood
disease epidemiology. Recently, there has also been considerable research on
the relation between diet and adult-onset diabetes mellitus in Greece.16,17
It is neither essential nor realistic to summarize this evidence for the purposes
of the present document, but it is useful to highlight the key findings with
special reference to the contemporary Greek situation.
- Nutrient deficiencies are
highly unlikely to occur when the recommended nutrient intakes are met, as
they usually are in most industrialized countries. Special attention is still
required with respect to calcium intake for the prevention of osteoporosis,
iron intake for the prevention of iron, deficiency anemia, folic acid intake
for the prevention on neural tube defects, iodine intake for the prevention
of goiter and fluoride intake for the prevention of dental caries.
- Energy intake has occasionally
been erroneously perceived by the public as adversely affecting health. In
reality, when body mass index (BMI) is adjusted for, higher energy intake
is associated with lower cardiovascular and total mortality, because, in this
instance, energy intake equals energy expenditure, which is partially determined
by physical activity. In fact, it is physical inactivity and obesity that
adversely affect health, the former by increasing the risk of cardiovascular
diseases, osteoporosis, colorectal cancer and possibly other forms of cancer,
and the latter by increasing the risk of non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus,
hypertension and dislipidemias. In other words, between two persons with the
same BMI, the one who consumes more food is likely to be healthier than the
one who consumes less food. It is noted that central (male-type) obesity is
generally considered more disease-conducive than peripheral (female-type)
obesity.
- Consumption of whole grain
cereals has not been posi tively associated with a particular disease, and
may reduce the risk of diverticulosis and constipation. The glycemic effect
of starchy foods, often measured as the glycemic index, depends on the rate
of digestion, which is in turn determined to same extent by the fiber content,
but mainly by the availability of starch for digestion. Leavening and baking
increase the glycemic effect of starch in bread, but starch in pasta and pulses
has a low and retarded glycemic effect. In hypertriglyceridemic people, long-term
consumption of low-glycemic index foods may reduce the risk of cardiovascular
diseases by improving glucose tolerance, reducing insulin secretion and lowering
blood lipids.
- Potatoes provide as much percentage
energy from protein as do wheat and rice, and are a good source of vitamin
C. Like white bread, however, potatoes have a high glycemic index because
they are rapidly converted to glucose after being consumed. Potato consumption
has been found to be positively associated with the risk of type 2 diabetes
in men and women.
- Consumption of simple sugars
has been associate with increased occurrence of dental caries particularly
in the absence of water fluoridation and proper hygienic measures. The glycemic
effects of simple sugars are mainly comparable to or less than those of starch
from cooked foods.
- Vegetables and fruits have
been inversely associated with the occurrence of coronary heart disease and
most common cancers, probably on account of their high content in dietary
fiber, folic acid, vitamin C, beta-carotene, other carotenoids, polyphenols
and phytoestrogens.
- Pulses have not been consistently
associated with a particular disease, in spite of some reports of a positive
association with stomach cancer. Their glycemic effects are lower than those
of starchy foods, and their high protein and low fat content increases their
nutritional appeal.
- There is strong evidence that
dietary fiber from cereals, pulses, vegetables and fruits has a beneficial
role in controlling constipation, preventing diverticular disease, and favorably
affecting blood lipid profile and the regulation of diabetes mellitus.
- Nuts are a good source of
monounsaturated fatty acids and several types of nuts have been shown to have
hypocholesterolemic effects. Seeds are frequently considered together with
nuts and, like nuts, they also have a high content of vitamin E and fiber.
To the extent that energy intake does not exceed energy expenditure, nuts
and seeds can be among the healthier choices of a snack.
- Meat and eggs provide high
quality protein. Meat also contains vitamins of the B complex and selenium.
Moreover, it is rich in iron and zinc, but excess intake of these minerals
in adult life is not necessarily beneficial. Furthermore, intake of meat,
particularly red meat, has been consistently associated with colorectal cancer
and inconsistently with other forms of cancer and coronary heart disease.
Both meat and eggs contain rela tively high quantities of cholesterol and
this should always be taken into account, even though dietary cholesterol
is not the major contributor to serum cholesterol levels.
- Fish (especially those high
in lipids) and seafood consumption has been reported to reduce the risk of
coronary heart disease, possibly because these foods contain high quantities
of long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids.
- The health implications of
high consumption of milk and dairy products have not been conclusively documented.
On the one hand, these foods are rich in calcium, but on the other, they can
also be an important source of saturated fat. Consumption of fat-free dairy
products theoretically provides many advantages which, however, have not yet
been documented.
- Saturated fatty acids have
been positively associated with coronary heart disease, cancer of the prostate,
probably cancer of the large bowel and possibly other forms of cancer. Trans
fatty acids, which can be found in many margarines and certain food products
(e.g. biscuits), have similar or even worse properties than those of saturated
fatty acids. Polyunsaturated fatty acids are generally considered beneficial
to the heart because they reduce low density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol
in the blood, even though they also tend to decrease the level of high density
lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, an undesirable effect. Polyunsaturated fatty
acids, however, have been implicated in animal carcinogenesis and even human
carcinogenesis in some studies. Long chain ω-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids
have been inconsistently reported to reduce the risk of coronary heart disease,
perhaps by affecting thrombogenesis and reducing blood triglyceride levels.
Monounsatu rated fatty acids, and in particular olive oil, have been reported
to be inversely associated with breast cancer and perhaps other forms of cancer
and are known to reduce LDL cholesterol, without reducing HDL cholesterol.
In fact, olive oil has been found to have either a beneficial effect or no
adverse effect with respect to any chronic human disease that has been investigated,
including osteoporosis and non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. This may
be related to its high content in the monounsaturated oleic acid and to the
abundance of antioxidant compounds, which are mainly present in the virgin
olive oil. Lipids, irrespective of type, are presumed to facilitate weight
gain, but the human evidence is inconclusive.
- Water does not generate energy,
but it is crucial for life and can also be an important source of essential
elements such as iodine and fluoride. Availability of chemi cally and microbiologically
safe water is crucial for good health and its intake is adequately regulated
by thirst, except occasionally among the elderly. Non alcoholic beverages,
including sodas, have not been conclusively linked to health effects. Fruit
juices are likely to share some of the benefits of fruits, whereas other beverages
have been cri ticized for their high content in simple carbohydrates.
- Ethanol consumption increases
the risk for cancer of the upper gastrointestinal track, particularly among
smokers, is an important cause of liver cirrhosis and chronic pancreatitis,
and may even contribute to the causation of breast cancer and possibly colon
cancer. Moreover, alcoholism can be a major social problem. Nevertheless,
the strong protective effect of ethanol and perhaps, other constituents of
some alcoholic beverages against cardiovascular diseases has made the formulation
of recommendations by health authorities particularly difficult. A consensus
is now being formed that moderate alcohol consumption, particularly in the
form of wine and especially during meals, is beneficial for the average person.
Guidelines, however, should be adjusted to take into account family history
of alcoholism, liver disease, smoking habits and even gender (the benefit-to-risk
ratio is more favorable for men than for women).
- Sound epidemiological evidence
can only exist for added substances under individual control, notably salt
and other condiments. Salt contributes to the development of hypertension
among predisposed individuals. It is also likely that it contributes to the
development of stomach cancer. For other condiments widely consumed in Greece
no conclusive evidence about their health effects exists. It is obvious that
the concentration of all contaminants should be minimized to the extent this
is possible.
4. THE
NEED TO ESTABLISH FOOD-BASED DIETARY GUIDELINES FOR THE GREEK POPULATION
Several countries have formulated
their own national FBDG.9 The United States FBDG,18
depicted in the form of a food pyramid, have widely publicized and can be accessed
through the internet (http://www.pueblo. gsa.gov/cic_text/food/dietgd/dietgd.html).
A Harvard-led group, with substantial input from Greek scientists, has also
developed an alternative pyramid based on the principles of the traditional
Mediterranean diet.19 Within Europe, several countries have
developed their own FBDG. A report to the European Parliament20
pointed out that the traditional Mediterranean diet has several advantages over
other traditional healthy dietary patterns. The development of FBDG for Europe
is currently the objective of a large European Union funded project. In Greece,
the Ministry of Health has issued a poster depicting a Greek version of the
Harvard developed Mediterranean diet pyramid, acknowledging the importance of
this pattern for the health of the Greek population (Greek Ministry of Health,
Division of Health Education, Mediterranean Diet Pyramid poster. Source: National
Nutrition Center). Moreover, the Hellenic Supreme Scientific Health Council
has recently called for the development of a document summarizing FBDG for the
Greek population, taking into account evidence from studies in this population.
The reasons dictating the development of FBDG specifically for the Greek population
are the following:
- In the late 1960s, Greece
enjoyed low mortality rates from coronary heart disease and several forms
of cancer, conditions, which appear to have strong nutritional etiological
components. Increasing mortality from these diseases over the last three decades
has followed the westernization of the dietary patterns of a large segment
of the Greek population. This can be considered as evidence that the model
diet for the Greek population closely approximates the traditional Greek diet
in the late 1950s.
- A series of case-control studies,
undertaken in Greece during the last two decades, has provided evidence that
several forms of cancer, coronary heart disease and other chronic diseases2126
have powerful inverse relations with critical components of the traditional
Greek diet. These findings were compatible with those previously or subsequently
reported from other major studies.
- There has been a successful
attempt to operationalize the critical components of the traditional Greek
diet and translate them into a uni-dimensional score.27
This score has been found to predict total mortality in the Greek population,29,30
as well as in other populations. Essentially, these data confirm, at the appropriate
individual level, the ecological evidence generated by the classical Keys
study.15,31
- Several studies in Greece
have pointed out critical dietary changes3236 in the Greek
population. These changes could be targeted for reversal. Moreover, changes
in nutrition-related parameters, such as obesity and blood lipids, have been
identified and could represent important intermediate objectives in any strategy
for nutritional changes.
- There is a wealth of information
from the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) food balance sheets, household
budget surveys,37 surveys of healthy individuals,38
case-control studies,39 and the large prospecti ve European
study EPIC40 concerning the contemporary Greek diet and
its variation across socioeconomic strata. This information facilitates the
establishment of critical categories targeted for preservation or change.
- The Greek population, like
other Mediterranean popu lations, is unusual in its accessibility to olive
oil, a food which both is important in itself and also facilitates the adoption
of a versatile dietary pattern rich in fresh vegetables, as well as cooked
vegetables, pulses and even cereals.
- The existence of food composition
tables for Greek foods and recipes41 allows the translation
of dietary intakes into nutritional intakes.
- The proximity of the
tradition Greek diet to an optimal diet resolves the conflict between two
schools of thought, the one arguing that guidelines should focus on optimal
consumption and the other stating that guidelines should target realistic
changes.
- Dietary guidelines for the
Greek population should be as simple as possible. Experience with tobacco
smoking indicates that Greeks are highly resistant to health messages. People
should not be given the excuse that guidelines are, or appear to be, too sophisticated
to allow general adherence. Even simple guidelines, such as those of the United
States, require more attention than the average healthy Greek is ready to
dedicate to the scientific rationale for dietary guidelines.
5. DIETARY
GUIDELINES FOR THE GREEK POPULATION
It has become customary to represent
FBDG in the form of a triangle ("pyramid"), the base of which refers to foods
which are to be consumed most frequently and the top to those to be consumed
rarely, with the other foods occupying intermediate positions. In the food pyramid,
frequencies rather than exact quantities in grams are indicated, because most
consumers think in this way about the foods they consume.
Consideration of frequencies,
however, implies a standardized portion size, multiples of which are to be consumed.
These portions have been variously termed "servings" or, when foods of similar
origin or composition are considered, "equivalents".
A total of about 22 to 23 servings
are to be consumed daily, in three of four meals. In a rough approximation,
a serving equals one half of the portions as defined in the Greek market regulations
(approximately half the quantity served in a Greek restaurant). So, one serving
is equal to:
One slice of bread (25 g)
100 g potatoes
Half a cup (i.e. 5060 g) of
cooked rice or pasta
A cup of raw leafy vegetables
or half a cup of other vegetables, cooked or chopped (i.e. ~100 g of most vegetables)
One apple (80 g), one banana
(60 g), one orange (100 g), 200 g of melon or watermelon, 30 g of grapes
One cup of milk or yogurt
30 g of cheese
1 egg
~60 g of cooked lean meat or
fish
One cup (i.e. 100 g) of cooked
dry beans.
6. ENERGY
INTAKE AND EXPENDITURE
For adults, the maintenance of
a body mass index (BMI) of no more than 25 kg/m2 is a primary objective.42,43
BMI is defined as body weight in kilograms divided by the square of height in
meters. BMI does not exceed 25 kg/m2 when, for instance, an individual
of 1.80 m height weights less than 75 kilograms, an individual of 1.70 m weights
less than 65 kilograms, or an individual of 1.60 weight less than 55 kilograms.
A BMI below 25 kg/m2 is not associated with excess mortality and,
in fact, may be an advantage, unless the BMI value falls below.20
There are several tables of recommended values for energy intake, but nobody
should be expected to count daily caloric intake. In fact, increasing BMI should
be interpreted primarily as a need to increase physical activity, whereas reduction
of energy intake is the second and less desirable option. Even when BMI remains
constant below 25 kg/m2, daily physical activity equivalent to walking
briskly, swimming, dancing, climbing stairs or gardening for fifteen to thirty
minutes per day, preferably every day, is highly recommended.
7. FOOD
VARIABILITY
A wide variety of foods in the
diet minimizes the possibility that one particular nutrient, the biological
properties of which may have not yet been recognized, will not be grossly deficient
in the diet. Even foods which are currently considered as rather unhealthy,
do not have to be completely excluded from the diet, because they may contribute
one or more essential nutrients (e.g. meat as a source of B12 vitamin).
Moreover, no food in a usual diet should be considered as a poison to be avoided
by all means, except when particular individuals have a genetic or otherwise
induced susceptibility to certain foods (e.g. fava beans and G6PD deficiency).
8. FOOD
GROUPS
8.1. Cereals
Every day the diet, on the average,
should include about eight servings of cereals and cereal products, preferably
non refined ones, including bread. This guideline is not difficult to accommodate,
even in the contemporary Greek diet, since Greeks still consume a lot of bread.
Non refined cereals and their products provide a considerable amount of fiber,
which is a desirable attribute.
8.2. Potatoes
Though some classify potatoes
under vegetables, they nutritionally fit better under the category of cereals,
particularly refined ones. Like white bread, potatoes have been found to have
a high glycemic index and current nutrition advice is that they should not exceed
3 servings per week.
8.3. Sugars
Simple sugar are plentiful in
deserts, and also exist, or are added, in beverages, like coffee, tea, fruit
juices, soft drinks and colas. They are also naturally found in many fruits.
Simple sugars have glycemic effects mainly comparable to or less than those
of starch from cooked foods. Reduction of sugar intake can by accomplished through
training during the early years of life. The use of sugar substitutes, such
as saccharine and aspartame, has not been linked to human risk, but avoidance
of excess consumption may be prudent. Although many Greek deserts are prepared
with olive oil, a multitude of nuts, fruits and flour, rather than fresh cream
or butter, the average daily intake should not exceed half a serving per day,
or a serving every other day.
8.4. Vegetables
and fruits
Every day, on the average, the
diet should include about six servings of vegetables and three servings of fruits.
There is no risk in the excess intake of vegetables or fruits, so long as energy
expenditure balances energy intake. Vegetables and fruits provide a considerable
amount of fiber, several micronutrients (potassium, calcium, vitamin C, vitamin
B6, carotenoids, vitamin E, folate), as well as other compounds with
antioxidant potential. The wild greens traditionally consumed in Greece are
of particular interest, since they represent a rich source of antioxidants.
Vegetables may be consumed either cooked in olive oil, or raw in the form of
salads.
8.5. Pulses
Pulses are rarely consumed and
rarely independently considered in FBDG of most countries. In Greece, however,
olive oil allows the preparation of delightful dishes with pulses which share
some of the health attributes of vegetables and also provide protein, albeit
of moderate quality, consumption of an average of one serving every other day
is advised.
8.6. Herbs
Oregano, basil, thyme and other
herbs grown in Greece are a good source of antioxidant compounds and can be
a tasteful substitute for salt in the preparation of various dishes.
8.7. Meat
and eggs
Consumption of poultry, eggs
and red meat should not exceed on the average one serving per day, and further
reduction does not appear to compromise good health among adults. Poultry is
much preferred over red meat, and eggs, including those used for cooking or
baking, should not exceed 4 per week, so a person may consume 3 eggs and two
servings of poultry per week.
8.8. Fish
and seafood
Fish and seafood could physiologically
substitute meat and eggs, but culinary, practical and economic constraints dictate
a recommendation of about one serving per day.
8.9. Dairy
products
Consumption of an average of
two servings per day of dairy products, in the form of cheese, traditional yogurt
and milk appears compatible with good health and the culinary traditions of
the Greek population.
8.10. Added
lipids
Olive oil should be preferred
over other added lipids, in salads, fried or cooked foods. When the BMI is kept
below 25, there is no scientific reason to limit olive oil intake, notwithstanding
its high energy content. In a weight reducing diet, increasing physical activity
and reducing caloric intake are priorities. Foods do not affect BMI in ways
beyond those determined by their energy content. Specifically, reducing olive
oil intake may not be the preferred option if this is to be accompanied by the
reduction of vegetable and pulses intake, which are usually prepared with olive
oil.
8.11. Water
Thirst adequately regulates water
intake, except among the elderly and in some pathological conditions. In general
terms, the higher the energy consumption and expenditure, the greater the quantity
of water needed. Substitution of water by non-alcoholic beverages offers no
advantage.
8.12. Ethanol
Consumption of alcoholic beverages
equivalent to about 30 g of ethanol (three servings of most alcoholic beverages)
per day among men and 15 g of ethanol (one and a half servings of most alcoholic
beverages) per day among women have beneficial overall effects on health. There
is evidence that consumption of wine during meals is more beneficial than consumption
of spirits or beer outside meals, and some suggestion that red wine is more
beneficial than white wine.
8.13. Added
substances
As previously indicated, sound
epidemiological evidence can only exist for added substances under individual
control, notably salt and other condiments. Consumption of salt should be reduced
to the culinary acceptable minimum. Most processed foods already contain more
salt than needed for physiological purposes.
9. FOOD-BASED
DIETARY GUIDELINES AND NUTRIENT RECOMMENDATIONS
FBDG must cover, at least, the
AR of each nutrient (Commission of the European Communities, 1993). In order
to assure that this prerequisite is respected when adhering to the present FBDG,
the weighted mean nutrient content of each food group has been calculated. The
weighting was based on the relative frequency of consumption of the foods categorized
under each food group. The relative frequency of consumption was assessed based
on data on the food habits of healthy adult Greeks, who participated as controls
in a series of epidemiological studies on the nutritional etiology of chronic
diseases.39 The food-base dietary guidelines for Greek adults
were found to be in accordance with the nutrient recommendations of the European
Scientific Committee for Foods (Commission of the European Communities, 1993).
10. PICTORIAL
PRESENTATION OF THE FOOD-BASED DIETARY GUIDELINES
The pictorial presentation of
the FBDG outlined in this document is generally compatible with that suggested
by Willett et al.19 There are, however, some minor adjustments
to accommodate the evidence from recent studies. Furthermore, the guidelines
in this document are of semi-quantitative nature. The guidelines should be complemented
with simple, common since advice:
Do not exceed the optimal body
weight for your height
Eat slowly, preferably at regular
times during the day and in a pleasant environment
Prefer fruits and nuts as snacks,
instead of sweets or candy bars
Prefer whole grain bread or
pasta
Always prefer water over soft
drinks
Healthy adults, with the exception
of pregnant women, do not need dietary supplements (vitamins, minerals, etc.)
when they follow a balanced diet
Light foods are not a substitute
for physical activity when it comes to controlling excess body weight; furthermore,
their consumption in large quantities has been shown to promote obesity
Although the indicated model
diet is the ultimate goal, gradual adoption may be more realistic for some people.
REFERENCES
- TRICHOPOULOS D. The health
of Greeks: Yesterday, today and tomorrow (in Greek). Mat Med Gr 1989,
17:315320
- KATSOUYANNI K, KOGEVINAS M,
DONTAS N, NAISONNEUVE P, BOYLE P, TRICHOPOULOS D. Cancer mortality in Greece
19601985 (in Greek). Hellenic Society Against Cancer 1990:125
- TRICHOPOULOU A, LAGIOU P,
TRICHOPOULOS D. Traditional Greek diet and coronary heart disease. J Cardiovasc
Risk 1994, 1:9 15
- KALAPOTHAKI V, KALANDIDI A,
KATSOUYANNI K, TRICHOPOULOU A, KYRIOPOULOS J, KREMASTINOU J ET AL. The health
of the Greek population (in Greek). Mat Med Gr 1992, 20:91164
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION.
Tobacco or HealthA Global Status Report. Geneva, WHO, 1997
- COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES. Reports of the Scientific Committee for Foods (Thirty-first series).
Nutrient and energy intakes for the European Commission. Luxembourg, Office
for Official Publications of the European Community, 1993
- NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL.
Diet and Health: Implications for reducing chronic disease risk. National
Academy Press, Washington DC, USA, 1989
- WORLD CANCER RESEARCH FUND-AMERICAN
INSTITUTE FOR CANCER RESEARCH. Food Nutrition and the Prevention of Cancer:
a Global Perspective, 1997
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANISATION.
Preparation and use of food-based dietary guidelines. WHO Technical Report
Series 880, WHO Geneva, 1998
- WILLETT WC. Diet and health:
what should we eat? Science 1994, 264:532537
- WILLETT WC, HUNTER DJ. Prospective
studies of diet and breast cancer. Cancer 1994, 74(Suppl 3):10851089
- RIMM EB, ASCHERIO A, GIOVANNUCCI
E, SPIEGELMAN D, STAMPFER MJ, WILLETT WC. Vegetable, fruit and cereal fiber
intake and risk of coronary heart disease among men. JAMA 1996, 275:447451
- PLATZ EA, GIOVANNUCCI E, RIMM
EB, ROCKETT HR, STAMPFER MJ, COLDITZ EA ET AL. Dietary fiber and distal colorectal
adenoma in men. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 1997, 6:661670
- WILLETT WC. The dietary pyramid:
does the foundation need repair? Am J Clin Nutr 1998, 68:218219
- KEYS A. Seven Countries:
A Multivariate Analysis of Death and Coronary Heart Disease. Cambridge,
Harvard University Press, 1980
- VOYATZOGLOU D, LOUPA C, PHILIPPIDES
P, SISKOUDIS P, KITSOU E, ALEVIZOU V ET AL. Insulin response to legumes in
type 2 diabetic persons. Eur J Int Med 1995, 6:201203
- KATSILAMBROS N, KOSTALAS G,
MICHALAKIS N, KAPANTAIS E, MAN GLARA E, KOUZELI CH ET AL. Metabolic effects
of long-term diets enriched in olive oil or sunflower oil in non-insulin-dependent
diabetes. Nut Metab Cardiovasc Dis 1996, 6:164167
- US DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE-US
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES. Nutrition and Your Health: Dietary
Guidelines for Americans. 4th ed, 1995
- WILLETT WC, SACKS F, TRICHOPOULOU
A, DRESCHER G, FERRO-LUZZI A, HELSING E ET AL. Mediterranean diet pyramid:
a cultural model for health eating. Am J Clin Nutr 1995, 61:1402S1406S
- TRICHOPOULOU A. Nutrition
in Europe: Nutrition policy and public health in the European Community and
models for European eating habits on the threshold of the 21st century. Scientific
and Technological Options Assessment (STOA), European Parliament, Directorate
General for Research, Luxembourg, 1997
- MANOUSOS O, DAY NE, TZONOU
A, PAPADIMITRIOU C, KAPETANAKIS A, POLYCHRONOPOULOU-TRICHOPOULOU A ET AL.
Diet and other factors in the etiology of diverticulosis: an epidemiological
study in Greece. Gut 1985, 26:544549
- TRICHOPOULOS D, OURANOS G,
DAY NE, TZONOU A, MANOUSOS O, PAPADIMITRIOU C ET AL. Diet and cancer of the
stomach: a case-control study in Greece. Int J Cancer 1985, 36:291297
- KATSOUYANNI K, SKALKIDIS Y,
PETRIDOU E, POLYCHRONOPOULOU-TRICHOPOULOU A, WILLETT W, TRICHOPOULOS D ET
AL. Diet and peri phe ral arterial occlusive disease: the role of poly-, mono,
and saturated fatty acids. Am J Epidemiol 1991, 133:2431
- TRICHOPOULOU A, KATSOUYANNI
K, STUVER S, TZALA L, GNARDELLIS Ch, RIMM E ET AL. Consumption of olive oil
and specific food groups in relation to breast cancer risk in Greece. J
Natl Cancer Inst 1995, 87:110116
- TZONOU A, SIGNORELLO LB, LAGIOU
P, WUU J, TRICHOPOULOS D, TRICHOPOULOU A. Diet and cancer of the prostate:
a case-control study in Greece. Int J Cancer 1999, 80:704708
- LAGIOU P, WUU J, TRICHOPOULOU
A, HSIEH C-C, ADAMI H-O, TRICHOPOULOS D. Diet and benign prostatic hyperplasia:
a study in Greece. Urology 1999, 54:284290
- TRICHOPOULOU A, KOURIS-BLAZOS
A, VASSILAKOU T, GNARDELLIS Ch, POLYCHRONOPOULOS E, VENIZELOS M ET AL. The
diet and survival of elderly Greeks; a link to the past. Am J Clin Nutr
1995, 61: 1346S1350S
- TRICHOPOULOU A, KOURIS-BLAZOS
A, WAHLQVIST ML, GNARDELLIS Ch, LAGIOU P, POLYCHRONOPOULOS E ET AL. Diet and
overall survival in elderly people. Br Med J 1995, 311:14571460
- OSLER M, SCHROLL M. Diet and
mortality in a cohort of elderly people in a North European Community. Int
J Epidemiol 1997, 26:155159
- KOURIS-BLAZOS A, GNARDELLIS
Ch, WAHLQVIST ML, TRICHOPOULOS D, LUKITO W, TRICHOPOULOU A. Are the advantages
of the Mediterranean diet transferable to other populations? A cohort study
in Melbourne, Australia. Br J Nutr 1999, 82:5761
- KEYS A, MENOTTI A, KARVONEN
MJ, ARAVANIS C, BLACKBURN H, BUZINA R ET AL. The diet and 15-year death rate
in the Seven Countries Study. Am J Epidemiol 1986, 124:903915
- TRICHOPOULOU A, EFSTATHIADIS
P. Changes of nutrition patterns and health indicators at the population level
in Greece. Am J Clin Nutr 1989, 49:10421047
- KAFATOS A, DIACATOU A, LABADARIOS
D, KOUNALI D, APOSTOLAKI J, VLACHONIKOLIS J ET AL. Nutrition status of the
elderly in Anogia, Crete, Greece. J Am Coll Nutr 1993, 12:685692
- TRICHOPOULOU A, KATSOUYANNI
K, GNARDELLIS Ch. The traditional Greek diet. Eur J Clin Nutr 1993,
47(Suppl 1):S76S81
- KAFATOS A, DIACATOU A, VOUKIKLARIS
G, NIKOLAKAKIS N, VLACHONIKOLIS J, KOUNALI D ET AL. Heart disease risk-factor
status and dietary changes in the Cretan population over the past 30 y: the
Seven Countries Study. Am J Clin Nutr 1997, 65:18821886
- ROMA-GIANNIKOU E, ADAMIDIS
D, GIANNIOU M, NIKOLARA R, MATSANIOTIS N. Nutritional survey in Greek children:
nutrient intake. Eur J Clin Nutr 1997, 51:273285
- TRICHOPOULOU A. Monitoring
food intake in Europe: a food data bank based on household budget surveys.
Eur J Clin Nutr 1992, 46(Suppl 5):S3S8
- KAFATOS A, MAMALAKIS G. Changing
patterns of fat intake in Crete. Eur J Clin Nutr 1993, 47(Suppl 1):S21S24
- TRICHOPOULOS D, TZONOU A,
KATSOUYANNI K, TRICHOPOULOU A. Diet and cancer: the role of case-control studies.
Ann Nutr Metab 1991, 35(Suppl 1):8992
- GNARDELLIS C, BOULOU C, TRICHOPOULOU
A. Magnitude, determinants and impact of under-reporting of energy intake
in a cohort study in Greece. Public Health Nutr 1998, 1:131137
- TRICHOPOULOU A. Composition
of Greek foods and dishes (in Greek and English). Athens, Athens School
of Public Health, 1992
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANISATION.
Energy and protein requirements. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO/UNU Expert Consultation.
WHO Technical Report Series 724, WHO, Geneva, 1985
- WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION.
Diet, nutrition and the prevention of chronic disease. Technical Report Series
797, WHO, Geneva, 1990